A woman with curly hair and glasses sitting behind a bakery counter with baked goods in clear plastic bags and containers.

Custom Cakes

It’s easy to order a custom cake! Follow the these steps:

Take a look at our Cake Book
(Pages 8 - 12 of the Cake Book list our "Classic Combinations" and simple designs for 6" and 9" cakes. You can order these cakes online for in-store pickup here.)
Fill out the Custom Cake Form and a member of our Custom Cake Team will get back to you within two business days. Need to contact us? Email us at custom@btwbakery.com.

Custom Cake Form

Subject

Please include your name in the subject line.

Name

First Name

Last Name

Email Address

Phone Number

(###)

###

####

Pick-up Location

We only offer delivery for orders of $500 or more; delivery originates at our production facility in Pleasantville, NY, not at any of our retail locations.

Date of Event

MM

DD

YYYY

Pick-up Time

Must be during business hours. See our Visit Us page for more info.

Hour

Minute

Second

Have you looked through our online Cake Book?

Pages 5 through 7 provide serving and pricing information for our different sizes of cakes. Pages 8 and 9 list our classic flavor configurations.

Yes

No

How many guests are you expecting?

What is the nature of your event (birthday, anniversary, shower, etc.)?

Do you have a budget we should be respectful of?

We are a dedicated gluten-free and dairy-free facility; everything we make is gluten and dairy free. We are also a peanut-free facility. While none of our layer cake batters, fillings, or frostings contain nuts, we are not a nutfree facility. Are they any other allergies we should be aware of?

Wedding Cakes

Your guests will admire your beautiful wedding cake and enjoy their slice without ever knowing that it's gluten-free and dairy-free. Fill out the Wedding Cake form to get started! Need to contact the Wedding Cake Team? Email us at weddings@btwbakery.com.

Wedding Cake Form

Subject

Please include your name in the subject line.

Your Name

First Name

Last Name

Your Fiancé(e)'s Name

First Name

Last Name

Email Address

Phone Number

(###)

###

####

Wedding Date

MM

DD

YYYY

Venue Address, if delivery

Wedding Planner Information, if any

Ingredient Information

Please review our Ingredient Summary. Send us an email at ingredients@btwbakery.com for more detailed information.

Kosher Certification

If you don't see the answer to your question after reviewing the Kosher Certification and FAQ sections, please email your question to kosher@btwbakery.com.

Contact Us

Custom Cakes

Wedding Cakes

Ingredient Information

Kosher Certification